DSLR Photography Forum
freezing river morning - Printable Version

+- DSLR Photography Forum (https://www.shuttertalk.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Digital Photography Forum (https://www.shuttertalk.com/forums/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Photo Critique (https://www.shuttertalk.com/forums/forum-26.html)
+--- Thread: freezing river morning (/thread-14753.html)


freezing river morning - gerainte - Jan 4, 2014

Hi any suggestions on these would be appreciated , one the blue one is HDR. The first I have tried.

http://500px.com/photo/55948750

http://500px.com/photo/56787314


RE: freezing river morning - bethanhearne81 - Jan 4, 2014

Second pic is my personal favourite, I love how you captured the orange and the way the water is moving.

RE: freezing river morning - gerainte - Jan 4, 2014

(Jan 4, 2014, 14:56)bethanhearne81 Wrote:  Second pic is my personal favourite, I love how you captured the orange and the way the water is moving.

Thanks for your positive comment.

I've just noticed what I think are spots on the sensor seen in the sky what do people think?



RE: freezing river morning - bethanhearne81 - Jan 4, 2014

Yes it does look like it could be that, easily edited out Wink

(Jan 4, 2014, 15:13)gerainte Wrote:  
(Jan 4, 2014, 14:56)bethanhearne81 Wrote:  Second pic is my personal favourite, I love how you captured the orange and the way the water is moving.

Thanks for your positive comment.

I've just noticed what I think are spots on the sensor seen in the sky what do people think?



RE: freezing river morning - Phil J - Jan 4, 2014

gerainte,

For my money it has to be Number Two. Obviously it's only a personal opinion, but two is far and away the better one.

Best regards.

Phil.

RE: freezing river morning - Dean - Jan 5, 2014

I like them both. Very different moods.

RE: freezing river morning - gerainte - Jan 5, 2014

thanks for the comments. first time with HDR and it is very different effect, just about natural, as it was -3.
I do like both and it's interesting to hear other views. thanks

RE: freezing river morning - John M - Jan 5, 2014

I like the first one. It hardly looks like HDR (which is a good thing), so many people go over the top with HDR . I think it might be even better as monochrome - the colours do not bring so much with them - and concentrate on the lines and tones.

I do not like the second one, mainly because I do not like sunsets/rises.

RE: freezing river morning - gerainte - Jan 5, 2014

(Jan 5, 2014, 14:10)John M Wrote:  I like the first one. It hardly looks like HDR (which is a good thing), so many people go over the top with HDR . I think it might be even better as monochrome - the colours do not bring so much with them - and concentrate on the lines and tones.

I do not like the second one, mainly because I do not like sunsets/rises.

Not thought to look at it in B&W will try it and see, thanks for the suggestion

RE: freezing river morning - gerainte - Jan 5, 2014

Had a go in B&W and cropped to a square, this might be my favourite

http://500px.com/photo/56911074


RE: freezing river morning - John M - Jan 5, 2014

I like that.

RE: freezing river morning - Dean - Jan 5, 2014

Yes, like the B&W

RE: freezing river morning - gerainte - Jan 5, 2014

Thanks for the comments and the suggestion of B&W