bottle and cork (5 small size images) - Printable Version

+- DSLR Photography Forum (https://www.shuttertalk.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Digital Photography Forum (https://www.shuttertalk.com/forums/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Photo Critique (https://www.shuttertalk.com/forums/forum-26.html)
+--- Thread: bottle and cork (5 small size images) (/thread-2005.html)

---

bottle and cork (5 small size images) - Irma - Feb 11, 2005

What do you think about this?

---

bottle and cork (5 small size images) - EnglishBob - Feb 11, 2005

I like the first one the most, the color and lighting in it seem better. Great series.

---

bottle and cork (5 small size images) - Irma - Feb 11, 2005

Thanks Bob I placed everything near the window, and yes, the sky was clearer when I took the first one.

---

bottle and cork (5 small size images) - Petographer - Feb 11, 2005

I like #4 for the comp. You can read the label. But it is much too dark. I think this is the best one. Can you clean it up?

---

bottle and cork (5 small size images) - Irma - Feb 11, 2005

I think yes, maybe a little contrast will do. I'll try Thanks for your comment BTW.

---

bottle and cork (5 small size images) - Toad - Feb 11, 2005

I like the color one best - because the green makes the bottle stand out - in the other shots, I tend to see only the cork and not realize that there is a bottle lurking in the shadows. I think #4 has the best composition.

---

bottle and cork (5 small size images) - Irma - Feb 11, 2005

Here is #4 lightened, but what do you think about the reflection in the bottle? Could it be taken as a mistake in the picture? I really don't know what to do with this... :|

---

bottle and cork (5 small size images) - Irma - Feb 11, 2005

Toad; yes I like the green color with the background. Thanks for your comment

---

bottle and cork (5 small size images) - Petographer - Feb 11, 2005

How about this. I used my favorite tool Shadow/highlight and removed the shadowing. I used the dodge tool to help bring out the lettering in areas that were dark. I then selected the area from the cork back and applied a gaussian blur and viola! I think it could have used a counter clockwise rotation of 2 degrees.

---

bottle and cork (5 small size images) - Irma - Feb 11, 2005

Hey, you are great! You did it beautifuly... I won't forget your favorite tool anymore... Thanks a lot!!

---

bottle and cork (5 small size images) - slejhamer - Feb 11, 2005

Getting good light with glass is quite a challenge. Backlighting or bottom-lighting bottles is very common. Controlling reflections is a separate issue - you can use a combination of black and white reflectors placed strategically around the bottle to offset them.

This is a bit off topic, but it might give you some food for thought:
http://www.tabletopstudio.com/documents/glass_photography.htm

And look how complex this studio setup is, just to photograph a few bottles!
http://www.pwcphoto.com/Sets/Colored_Bottles/colored-bottle-set.htm

---

bottle and cork (5 small size images) - Irma - Feb 11, 2005

After watching this studio, I can see that it is very difficult to get something really good. However, I will read the article, it gives advice and probably I can improve my picture. Thanks for your comment

Thanks patch for your comment. I would love to see your pictures, if you tried.

My favorite is number #5 because it shows the shape of the bottle, and I don't need the lable to show that it is a bottle... However, I will give another try, I'm sure that with your comments, my next series will be much better

---

bottle and cork (5 small size images) - patch17 - Feb 11, 2005

very interesting irma. i like the first shot. but i would have prefered to crop out the label on the bottle, it's a little distracting.

hmmm... i'd like to try some out later.

---