Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Wishing Tree
#1

[Image: 1122018113_zakia-L.jpg]

At the Museum of Modern Art (New York), there's a tree where people are invited to write down their wish…

matthewpiers.com • @matthewpiers | robertsonphoto.blogspot.com | @thewsreviews • thewsreviews.com
Reply
#2

There's something poignant about wishes in general - wishing wells, wish books, wishing trees. Possibly wishes are a form of visualization - and that by visualizing wishes, we can maybe make them real.

The writer wishes that someone though (s)he was special. God - haven't we all felt that?
Reply
#3

Great Picture!!!

It made me think a lot about self esteem, the need of supporting people around you, fear of show how special you are....

I wish the one that wrote this wish finds that someone in him/herself.

A work of art which did not begin in emotion is not art.
Paul Cezanne
Reply
#4

An interesting choice of subject Matthew.

I wish someone thought I was special. 'Were' is plural if I am not mistaken. Education is the answer. Big Grin

I spent a while reading cards on a christmas tree in a stately home earlier this year, and also in China at a monastery. (The ones in english that is.)

Lumix LX5.
Canon 350 D.+ 18-55 Kit lens + Tamron 70-300 macro. + Canon 50mm f1.8 + Manfrotto tripod, in bag.
Reply
#5

The rule says you can say I wish I were or He treated me as if I were.... so to my understanding were is not always plural.

Now, the thing here is "someone thought" that comes in the middle. I think it is ok anyway, because someone thought belongs to the first part of the sentence. I am not so sure, but I think this is the subjunctive form?

Hallo Zig!!! ... Smile

A work of art which did not begin in emotion is not art.
Paul Cezanne
Reply
#6

Wahay!
Top marks Irma.
In English, the forms of both the present subjunctive and the conditional tenses are quite similar and easily confused even for native speakers. Interestingly enough, there exists in English dialect across the UK, echoes of the old kingdoms and demarcation zones of immigrant peoples who spoke slightly different Germanic tongues. East Midland dialect became the standard form of English, roughly equating with Mercia, whereas north of the rivers Trent and Humber existed many more words from Danish, Icelandic and Old Norse. Verb inflections and case endings varied somewhat, and many differences still remain in regional speech. Many a northern Englishperson will say, "I were going along the road," instead of the now-standard "was": both are uses of the same tense: past imperfect...it's just that long ago a Saxon(for example) had a completely different word than a Dane.
Another one: in Anglo-Saxon, a word to describe the anticipation of a future event, was "hwintil"; the Norse(I think) version, though similar, was still different: "hwil". Even today, in standard English, a southerner will say, " I won't see you until Thursday", whereas a northerner who comes from the old Viking Danegeld of the 9th/10 century(certainly around where NT lives), will say, " I won't see you while Thursday."
Anyway.
I feel Matthew's image to be even more poignant given its language code: broken English suggesting a broken soul, perhaps.

All my stuff is here: www.doverow.com
(Just click on the TOP RIGHT buttons to take you to my Image Galleries or Music Rooms!)
My band TRASHVILLE, in which I'm lead guitarist: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6mU6qaNx08
Reply
#7

Walking through the gallery, a week into my visit to New York, I was pretty busy thinking my own thoughts. Being amazed at some of the artwork, annoyed by a lack of signage, thinking about what was past and what's next - I was pretty self-contained. Seeing this was like getting hit by a giant "reset" button.

If it's hard for me to read, what must it be like to write it?

… part of its appeal to me is that this is someone who has written the way they speak. Break the lines a little differently and it's a poem, or perhaps it's best just the way it is.

thanks, Zig - you're a treasure as always.

matthewpiers.com • @matthewpiers | robertsonphoto.blogspot.com | @thewsreviews • thewsreviews.com
Reply
#8

Thanks Zig for your explanation. Always fascinating to learn something you don't easily read in text books. They just give you the rule that you need to learn in order to pass the exam. But at the end they don't train you to speak and understand native English people. Smile

A work of art which did not begin in emotion is not art.
Paul Cezanne
Reply
#9

I was thinking of the similarities. Wishing trees in different cultures.

[Image: IMG_0911.jpg]

Lumix LX5.
Canon 350 D.+ 18-55 Kit lens + Tamron 70-300 macro. + Canon 50mm f1.8 + Manfrotto tripod, in bag.
Reply
#10

So colorful picture NT. Beautiful indeed to see wishing trees in other countries. I don't think we have wishing trees in Mexico, and I haven't seen any in Germany...

Thanks for sharing your picture NT... Smile

A work of art which did not begin in emotion is not art.
Paul Cezanne
Reply
#11

It was a nice shot dear Matthew, Wishing Tree, we have too in our culture!

Thank you,
with my love,
nia

“There are no rules for good photographs, there are only good photographs.”

Ansel Adams



Reply
#12

Yoko Ono has had several art installations where people were invited to fasten their wishes to trees. I have a real soft spot for interactive art such as this.....unlike photography, it can never reflect a concrete image as the work itself is collaborative in nature and changes with the make up of the participants. This tree looked different before this wish was attached and looked different probably not 5 minutes later as more wishes were added. Catching it at this moment, with this sentiment highlighted is wonderful and thought provoking.
Lori
Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread / Author Replies Views Last Post
Last Post by webber
Oct 6, 2018, 09:53

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)